Honest Review: Rushing In by Claire Kingsley

by Theja Pk
0 comment
paperback of rushing in by Claire Kingsley laying on top of loose paper surrounded by beige decor

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I'll get a commission if you decide to purchase through my links, at NO extra cost to you. Please read my disclosure for more info.

Last updated on February 15th, 2024

In this week’s review, we will take a look at Rushing In by Claire Kingsley.

The 4th book in the Bailey Brothers Series recounts the story of Gavin, the youngest Bailey Brother, and Skylar, the daughter of Gavin’s boss.

I was excited to read this book because Gavin is my favorite of the brothers- charming, fearless, and hilarious. But sadly, this was disappointing after the great stories that Asher and Evan got in the previous books.

Rushing In – Claire Kingsley

2.8 out of 5
illustrated book cover of rushing in by Claire Kingsley showing river running between two mountains

GENRE: Contemporary Romance
PUB DATE: November 26, 2020
TROPEs: forbidden love, friends with benefits

A great option for readers who enjoy small-town, opposites-attract, or forbidden love with the boss’s daughter kind of romance. The characters are fun, and it’s an entertaining read.

3 out of 5
2 out of 5
3 out of 5
Overall Enjoyment
3 out of 5


chemistry between MCs

hilarious brotherly shenanigans

town mystery subplot


romance felt underdeveloped with overemphasis on physical connection

Gavin was portrayed much younger than he is

slow pacing

strange FMC personality traits that didn't make sense

Table of contents


With his dimpled grin and devilish charm, firefighter Gavin Bailey is hot as a five-alarm fire and twice as dangerous. The youngest of five brothers, he’s the daredevil of the family. Until the unexpected strikes, and he finds himself sidelined. 

Skylar Stanley’s life didn’t just fall apart. It exploded. Spectacularly. Dropped by her publisher and her agent, and dumped by her boyfriend, she suddenly has no place to live and a career circling the drain. She comes home to the quirky, feuding small town she hasn’t lived in since kindergarten to pick up the pieces. And hopefully, find her mojo. 

Gavin would happily help Skylar get her groove back – in and out of the bedroom – except for one big problem. Her dad is Gavin’s boss, mentor, and the closest thing he’s ever had to a father. 

As much as Gavin loves racing headlong into danger, Skylar is a risk of a different kind. One that he’s determined to avoid. 

But the line between friends and lovers gets awfully blurry, and Gavin just might find the one thing that truly scares him.  

Losing her. 


In classic opposites attract romance, Skylar is the shy girl to Gavin’s daredevil tendencies. Their chemistry is excellent, and I enjoyed how their contrasting personalities balanced each other out.

However, their relationship felt superficial and poorly developed beyond their insta-lust. I wanted more substance to their romance to root for them.

GAVIN was portrayed as much younger than he had seemed in previous books, with thoughts that ventured into the teenager category. SKYLAR was an okay character, but there were many strange aspects of her personality that I found hard to accept at face value without any logical reason. And her constant zoning out to think of possible book plots for her mystery books got tiresome and pulled away from the moment.

The rest of the BAILEY BROTHERS continue to add comedic moments and provide support when Gavin or any of the other brothers need someone to talk sense into them.


Despite the romance feeling rushed, the pacing of the overall book is pretty slow, with few significant things happening. We continue to solve the mystery of the hidden town’s treasure set up in the previous books, which was a fun puzzle-solving subplot.

I particularly enjoyed the subplot involving Skylar’s parents and their second-chance romance, which felt more believable than Gavin and Skylar’s.

The final conflict was consistent with Gavin’s character, and I appreciated how Skylar handled it. But it still felt like Kingsley skipped a lot of steps in their relationship, and I didn’t get to enjoy their journey as much if I had seen their romance grow gradually.


In Rushing In, the inner monologues felt more like young adult fiction than previous CK books. While Gavin is the youngest brother, I didn’t think this was necessary because he was in his mid-20s.

However, the dual points of view helped make the book more engaging.


Rushing In is a good option for readers who enjoy small-town, opposites-attract, or forbidden love with the boss’s daughter kind of romance.

The characters are fun, and it’s an entertaining read. However, due to the lack of romantic development and immature writing, it didn’t work out well for me.

If you’re keeping up with the series, check out the enemies-to-lovers story in the next book – Chasing Her Fire.

Cover Change

The series recently received an update with beautifully illustrated covers, which I must say are absolutely vibrant and capture the charming atmosphere of the small town.

But, I have to admit that I am a bit biased towards the originals because I think the men chosen to portray the brothers were a perfect match for their respective characters.


If you read Rushing In and have a different opinion, let me know in the comments below. I am always open to seeing a different perspective.

You may also like

Leave a Comment

Copyright @2024 – All Right Reserved. Designed and Developed by PenciDesign